OSHA AI Agent
Get instant answers to any safety question.
Request Demo
OSHA 1926SubpartPAppC

Timber shoring for trenches

Subpart P

38 Questions & Answers
10 Interpretations

Questions & Answers

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, when can I use the timber shoring tables in Appendix C for trench protection?

You can use the timber shoring tables in Appendix C only for trenches that do not exceed 20 feet (6.1 m) in depth and when the shoring design is being performed in accordance with 1926.652(c)(1). See Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 for the scope and application.

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, do I have to classify the soil before using the timber shoring tables?

Yes — you must determine the soil type using the soil classification method in Appendix A to Subpart P before using the timber shoring tables. Appendix C states that the data in its tables apply only when the soil type or types have been first determined using Appendix A, so follow 1926 Subpart P App C and the soil-classification method in 1926.652 when choosing member sizes.

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, is stable rock covered by the timber shoring tables?

No — stable rock is exempt from shoring requirements, and Appendix C provides no table data for stable rock. Appendix C explicitly states that "stable rock is exempt from shoring requirements," so you do not use the timber tables for that condition; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 and 1926.652 for context.

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, are timber member dimensions listed as nominal or actual sizes?

The timber member dimensions in the Appendix C tables refer to actual dimensions, not nominal dimensions. Appendix C states the sizes listed in Tables C–1.1 through C–1.3 refer to actual dimensions, so select members based on their actual measured size; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 and 1926.652(c)

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, when can I use nominal-size timber instead of actual dimensions?

You may use nominal-size timber by following the data in Tables C–2.1 through C–2.3 or by complying with the allowance in [1926.652(c)(3)]. Appendix C directs employers wanting to use nominal sizes to Tables C–2.1 through C–2.3 or other acceptable data sources such as The Corps of Engineers or the Bureau of Reclamation; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 and 1926.652(c)(3).

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, what conditions make the table-listed timber members inadequate?

The table-listed members are inadequate when certain conditions exist — for example: adjacent structure or stored-material loads exceeding a 2-foot soil surcharge; vertical loads on crossbraces exceeding a 240-pound gravity load on a one-foot center section; equipment surcharge loads over 20,000 pounds; or when only the lower portion of a trench is shored unless specific sloping or depth-based selection criteria are met. Appendix C lists these limitation conditions and directs that under such conditions you must design an alternate system in accordance with 1926.652(c) or use another type of protective system; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 for the full list.

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, how is “adjacent” defined for surcharge and loads affecting the trench?

"Adjacent" means the area within a horizontal distance from the edge of the trench equal to the trench depth. Appendix C defines the term "adjacent" this way when discussing surcharge and structural loads, so evaluate potential surcharge within that horizontal distance; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 and 1926.652 for related requirements.

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, what should I do if the trench will be saturated or submerged?

If trench conditions are saturated or submerged, you must use tight sheeting (special tongue-and-groove planks, steel sheet piling, or similar tight wall construction) to resist lateral water pressure and prevent loss of backfill. Appendix C Note 2 specifically requires tight sheeting when conditions are saturated or submerged; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 and 1926.652(c).

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, when must I use tight sheeting versus close sheeting?

Use tight sheeting when water must be resisted or retained (e.g., saturated/submerged conditions); close sheeting places planks side-by-side with minimal gaps and may be acceptable where water pressure is not an issue. Appendix C Note 2 defines tight sheeting and contrasts it with close sheeting and requires tight sheeting for water conditions; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 and 1926.652 for guidance.

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, how do I use the tables to pick member sizes for a trench?

You select member sizes by first determining soil type (Appendix A), then choosing the table for that soil type, and finally matching the trench width, depth, and chosen horizontal spacing of crossbraces to read the required crossbrace, wale, and upright sizes and spacings from the table. Appendix C explains this selection process and the need to choose horizontal crossbrace spacing before reading member sizes; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 and 1926.652(c).

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, are the spacing measurements center-to-center or edge-to-edge?

All spacing indicated in Appendix C tables is measured center-to-center. Appendix C Note 3 states that all spacing is measured center to center, so apply that measurement method when laying out crossbraces, wales, and uprights; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 for details.

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, how should wales be oriented when installed?

Wales must be installed with their greater (larger) dimension horizontal. Appendix C Note 4 requires installation of wales with the greater dimension horizontal, so select and place wales accordingly; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 and 1926.652 for context.

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, when must uprights be embedded or a mudsill used, and what are the maximum distances?

If the vertical distance from the center of the lowest crossbrace to the bottom of the trench exceeds 2.5 feet, uprights must be firmly embedded or a mudsill used; embedded uprights limit that vertical distance to 36 inches, while mudsills may be used up to 42 inches. Appendix C Note 5 explains these requirements and distances, so ensure upright embedment or mudsill placement meets these maximums; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 and 1926.652(c).

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, can trench jacks be used instead of crossbraces?

Yes — trench jacks may be used in lieu of or in combination with timber crossbraces. Appendix C Note 6 explicitly permits trench jacks as an alternative or supplement to crossbraces; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 and 1926.652(c) for design requirements.

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, how close must the top crossbrace be to the trench top?

When crossbrace vertical spacing is four feet, place the top crossbrace no more than two feet below the top of the trench; when spacing is five feet, place the top crossbrace no more than 2.5 feet below the trench top. Appendix C Note 7 provides these placement limits, so position the top crossbrace accordingly; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 and 1926.652(c).

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, what is "skip shoring" and is it allowed?

Skip shoring is an arrangement where crossbraces are spaced horizontally and some uprights are omitted (as in Arrangement B1 example), and Appendix C shows that skip shoring is an acceptable configuration when selected directly from the tables for the given soil, depth, width, and brace spacing. Appendix C's Example 1 describes skip shoring arrangements, so you may use skip shoring only as one of the acceptable table-listed arrangements for the applicable conditions; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 and 1926.652(c)(1).

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, how do I handle trenches deeper than 15 feet?

For trench sections over 15 feet in depth, Appendix C requires using the data in Table C–1.3; Appendix C Example 4 explains that member sizes and spacing for depths over 15 feet are determined from Table C–1.3, so follow that table and 1926.652(c) when designing shoring for deeper sections; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 for details.

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, what limit applies to vertical load on a crossbrace for using the tables?

If vertical loads on a crossbrace exceed a 240-pound gravity load distributed on a one-foot center section of the crossbrace, the table-specified members are not considered adequate and an alternative design per 1926.652(c) is required. Appendix C lists this 240-pound limit as a condition that invalidates the table data; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 for the limitation.

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, when can I mix shoring and sloping in the same trench?

You may combine shoring for the lower portion of a trench with sloping or benching for the remaining portion only if the sloped portion is sloped at an angle less steep than three horizontal to one vertical, or if members are selected from the tables for a depth measured from the top of the overall trench (not from the toe of the slope). Appendix C specifies these conditions and requires compliance with 1926.652(c); see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926.

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, what surcharge from equipment invalidates table use?

If a surcharge is imposed by equipment weighing more than 20,000 pounds, the table-specified timber members are not considered adequate and you must design an alternate protective system in accordance with [1926.652(c)]. Appendix C lists the 20,000-pound equipment surcharge as a disqualifying condition for the table data; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 for details.

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, what should I do if table spacing doesn't match my required spacing?

If member sizes or spacings other than those shown in the tables are needed, you must determine appropriate sizes and spacings by designing the protective system as specified in 1926.652(c), since Appendix C Note 1 directs that member sizes at spacings other than indicated be determined by that design procedure; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926.

Under 1926 Subpart P App C, how do the example arrangements (B1–B4) help in practice?

The example arrangements in Appendix C illustrate how to read the tables and select member sizes and spacing for a given soil type, trench depth, and width — they provide practical, acceptable configurations (including skip shoring) that meet the table criteria so you can follow the same selection steps for your trench. Appendix C includes Examples 1–4 to demonstrate table use and references 1926.652(c)(1) for design alignment; see Appendix C to Subpart P of Part 1926 for the examples.

Under 1926.652(c), can I use the timber shoring tables in Appendix C to design a trench protective system?

Yes. You may use the tabulated timber shoring requirements in Appendix C as a prescriptive method to install timber shoring when the site conditions and soil classification match the assumptions in those tables.

  • Appendix C provides minimum sizes and spacings for uprights, wales, and cross braces for different soil types, trench depths, and trench widths. See 1926.652(c) and 1926.652(c)(3).

(Reference: 1926.652(c) and Appendix C tables.)

Under 1926.652(c)(3), what must I do for trench protective systems deeper than 20 feet?

You must use an engineered design for trenches over 20 feet; the Appendix C tables direct you to "See Note 1" for depths over 20 ft, which requires a professional design.

  • 1926.652(c)(3) allows the use of tabulated data for protective systems but requires a registered professional engineer or equivalent when conditions fall outside those tables (for example, deeper than 20 ft, where Appendix C states "See Note 1").

(Reference: 1926.652(c)(3) and Appendix C.)

Under Appendix C, what surcharge pressure Pa should I use for soil types A, B, and C when reading the timber tables?

The Appendix C tables include an assumed surcharge pressure Pa for each soil type; use those values when applying the tables.

  • For Soil Type A the tables use Pa = 25 × H + 72 psf (2 ft. surcharge).
  • For Soil Type B the tables use Pa = 45 × H + 72 psf (2 ft. surcharge).
  • For Soil Type C the tables use Pa = 80 × H + 72 psf (2 ft. surcharge).

These Pa formulas and surcharge assumptions are shown in the headers of the timber shoring tables in Appendix C. Always confirm that your site surcharge conditions match the table assumptions; otherwise get an engineered design under 1926.652(c)(3).

(Reference: Appendix C timber tables and 1926.652(c)(3).)

Under Appendix C, can manufactured members of equivalent strength be substituted for the timber sizes listed in the tables?

Yes. Appendix C explicitly allows manufactured members of equivalent strength to be substituted for the wood members given in the tables.

  • The table footnotes state that "Manufactured members of equivalent strength may be substituted for wood," so you may use engineered steel or other manufactured members if they meet or exceed the strength assumed in the table designs. See the relevant footnotes in Appendix C.

(Reference: Appendix C and the prescription authority in 1926.652(c).)

Under Appendix C, what lumber strength or species assumptions are used in the timber shoring tables?

The tables include footnotes specifying minimum bending strengths or species assumptions for the timber used in those tables.

  • Some tables are based on "mixed oak or equivalent with a bending strength not less than 850 psi."
  • Other tables (S4S tables) are based on "Douglas fir or equivalent with a bending strength not less than 1500 psi."

Always use the table that matches the lumber specification you have available, or substitute manufactured members of equivalent strength. See the footnotes in Appendix C and confirm applicability under 1926.652(c).

(Reference: Appendix C table footnotes.)

Under Appendix C, what components and spacings do the timber shoring tables specify?

Appendix C tables specify the minimum sizes and spacings for the primary timber shoring components: cross braces, wales, and uprights, including both horizontal (maximum allowable horizontal spacing) and vertical spacings.

  • The tables present member sizes (uprights, wales, cross braces), their vertical spacing (distance between horizontal levels), and the maximum allowable horizontal spacing for the system, all keyed to trench depth, trench width, and soil type. See Appendix C.

(Reference: Appendix C timber tables and the authority in 1926.652(c).)

Under 1926.652, do I need to verify soil classification before choosing a timber table from Appendix C?

Yes. You must confirm the soil type (A, B, or C) and ensure site conditions match the assumptions for the table you use before applying Appendix C tabulated sizes.

  • Appendix C is organized by soil type and the tables assume the soil classification and surcharge conditions noted in each table header. If the soil is misclassified or conditions differ (e.g., water infiltration, vibration, or different surcharge), you cannot reliably use the table and should obtain an engineered protective system as required by 1926.652(c)(3).

(Reference: 1926.652(c) and Appendix C.)

Under Appendix C, what does the table entry labeled "Not Req'd" or a blank cell for maximum allowable horizontal spacing mean?

A table cell that reads "Not Req'd" or is left blank for maximum allowable horizontal spacing means that, for that specific combination of trench depth, trench width, and soil type, horizontal spacing limits are not required by the table (i.e., the table does not impose a horizontal spacing restriction for that configuration).

  • Even when the table does not specify a horizontal spacing requirement, you must ensure the protective system as installed is adequate for site conditions. If site conditions differ from the table assumptions, obtain a professional design under 1926.652(c)(3).

(Reference: Appendix C and 1926.652(c).)

Under Appendix C, if I increase trench width, how do the timber member sizes in the tables typically change?

As trench width increases the Appendix C tables generally call for larger timber members (bigger uprights and wales) and/or reduced spacings to resist the greater soil pressures.

  • The tables are organized so that for each soil type and depth, columns for wider trench widths list larger minimum member sizes or different spacing requirements. Consult the appropriate table for your trench width and depth in Appendix C.

(Reference: Appendix C timber tables and the prescriptive option in 1926.652(c).)

Under 1926.652, do surcharge conditions affect which Appendix C table I should use?

Yes. The Appendix C tables assume a specific surcharge condition (the tables indicate a 2‑ft surcharge and include Pa formulas that incorporate that surcharge). If your actual surcharge differs, you cannot rely on the table without verifying that the different surcharge will not increase loads beyond the table assumptions.

  • Appendix C explicitly shows Pa = (coefficient × H) + 72 psf, where the +72 psf represents a 2‑ft surcharge; see the table headings in Appendix C. If surcharges or adjacent loads are greater, obtain an engineered design as required by 1926.652(c)(3).

(Reference: Appendix C and 1926.652(c).)

Under 1926.652(c)(3), can I depart from the Appendix C tabulated shoring and use my own dimensions if I have calculations?

Yes — but only if your design is an engineered protective system prepared by a registered professional engineer or otherwise complies with the standard's requirements.

  • 1926.652(c)(3) requires protective systems that are not covered by the tabulated data to be designed by a qualified person (commonly a registered professional engineer). If you perform your own calculations, they must be part of a qualified engineer’s design or demonstrate equivalence to the table assumptions.

(Reference: 1926.652(c)(3) and Appendix C.)

Under Appendix C, what does the notation "S4S" mean in the timber table headings?

"S4S" stands for "surfaced four sides," meaning the lumber dimension given in that table is for dressed (planed) stock that has been surfaced on all four faces.

  • Some Appendix C tables specify sizes as "S4S" (surfaced four sides) while others give "size (actual)." Use the correct specification when selecting lumber, because dressed timber dimensions and properties can differ from rough-cut (nominal) dimensions. See the table headings and footnotes in Appendix C.

(Reference: Appendix C and the prescriptive provisions in 1926.652(c).)

Under Appendix C, what vertical spacings do the timber tables commonly require between horizontal members?

The tables commonly call for vertical spacings of about 4 to 6 feet between horizontal members (wales or cross braces), depending on soil type, trench depth, and trench width.

  • For many combinations the table vertical spacing values are 4 or 5 feet (and sometimes 6 feet) — you must read the correct table column that matches your trench depth and width. See the vertical spacing columns in the timber shoring tables in Appendix C.

(Reference: Appendix C timber tables.)

Under Appendix C, how do timber requirements differ between Soil Type A and Soil Type C?

Timber requirements for Soil Type C are more conservative (larger members and/or closer spacing) than for Soil Type A because Soil Type C is less stable and exerts higher loading on the shoring.

  • Appendix C organizes separate tables by soil type; Soil Type A tables are based on higher-strength lumber (for example, Douglas fir at 1500 psi in some tables) and show smaller member sizes than the tables for Soil Type C, which call for larger members to resist greater soil pressures. Consult the specific tables for your soil type and trench depth in Appendix C and confirm soil classification under 1926.652(c).

(Reference: Appendix C and 1926.652(c).)

Under 1926.652(c), are the Appendix C tables mandatory or an optional compliance method?

The Appendix C tables are an optional prescriptive method employers may use to meet the protective system requirements; they are not the only way to comply.

  • Employers may use the tabulated data in Appendix C when site conditions match the tables. Alternatively, employers can use manufacturer tabulated data or a protective system designed by a registered professional engineer as allowed under 1926.652(c)(3).

(Reference: 1926.652(c) and Appendix C.)

Under Appendix C, how do I pick the correct table column for my trench width?

Select the table column that corresponds to your measured trench width (the tables are organized by discrete width ranges); then use the row for your trench depth and the column for your soil type to read the required member sizes and spacings.

  • Each Appendix C table is keyed to trench width and depth. Choose the exact width column (or the range that contains your width), then follow across to find the minimum timber sizes, vertical spacing, and maximum allowable horizontal spacing for that configuration in Appendix C. If your width falls between columns or your conditions differ from assumptions, obtain an engineered design under 1926.652(c)(3).

(Reference: Appendix C tables and 1926.652(c).)